Book Review: The Country of Ice Cream Star

My name be Ice Cream Fifteen Star. This be the tale of how I bring the cure to all  the Nighted States, save every poory children, brief for life. Is how a city die for selfish love, and rise from this same smallness.  Be how the new America begin, in wars against all hope – a country with no power in a world that hate its life.  So been the faith I sworn, and it ain’t evils in no world nor cruelties in no red hell can change the vally heart of Ice Cream Star.

In the ruins of a future America, fifteen-year-old Ice Cream Star and her people survive by scavenging in the detritus of an abandoned civilization. Theirs is a world of children – by the time they reach the age of twenty, each of them will die of the disease they call posies.

When her brother sickens, Ice Cream sets out on the trail of a cure, led by a stranger whose intentions remain unclear. It’s a quest that will lead her to love and heartbreak, to captivity and to a nation’s throne, and ultimately into a war that threatens to doom everyone she loves.

I have been trying to review this book and I am struggling. So I’m going to say first-off: I LOVED IT. Maybe I need to find a better word than “love”. Because it’s not pretty. There’s very little “pretty” here.

The Country of Ice Cream Star by Sandra Newman is one of those books that dumps you in a world completely foreign to your own, and leaves you to figure it out as the story progresses. That is not to say there isn’t world-building (there is!), it just doesn’t make anything obvious.

I have never made quite so many annotations on my e-reader.

I don’t want to give anything away – even some smaller details take some reading to figure out, and I think that’s awesome.

One thing that takes a while to get used to is the language. Newman has essentially created a new dialect for her characters – I wouldn’t go so far as to call it a new language, but it is kind of a Pidgin English, although that’s not all too fair because it is not at all simplified. It reminds me a little of Valleysmen in Cloud Atlas. Eventually I really started enjoying this dialect, because it’s kind of similar to the way that I think, sometimes. Newman also REALLY displays her prowess when she brings other dialects into her story with other communities.

This book is LONG… I mean, not 1Q84 long, but 640 pages long. And it’s an epic, of war and disease and kinship. It took me a long time to finish it: it’s not the kind of book that should be rushed. It is also not at all predictable (at least, it wasn’t to me), which makes it an even wilder ride.

I would have love to read this in a class because there are a few parallels to modern world that could be discussed, especially in terms of religion, politics and war (although you could argue they are all the same). In many ways I was reminded of Lord of the Flies and The Handmaid’s Tale. Many parts of the story were gut-churning and decidedly not-pretty. Sometimes I wondered about the lack of moral fibre in these kids, and other times I marvelled at the structures they managed to build into their societies.

“You have to understand, it’s how we are here. It’s like we’re all asleep. We grow up, we fall asleep, and then the horrors that scared us before – we’re doing them. We’re the monsters in the nightmare.”

As for the main character, Ice Cream Star: I really enjoyed reading her – which is not to say I always liked her. Sometimes she annoyed the crap out of me. Sometimes I just wanted to hug her. Sometimes I felt like she didn’t really have full agency. But as a character she was wonderful. Her self-awareness and maturity change noticeably. It’s like you could see her prefrontal cortex developing.


In terms of story-development, this is probably one of the most unique books I’ve read. The idea of a plague killing everyone at a certain age is not new, but the way in which Newman further develops that idea certainly is. What happens when a cure is not found? What happens when the plague becomes the norm? What happens when children become responsible for humanity’s continued existence?

The Country of Ice Cream Star happens. I couldn’t recommend this book more avidly. (Somebody please read it soon so that I can have long discussions about it without spoiling the story!)

I received an eARC of this book via the publishers and NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.


  1. jessicaayn says:

    Hi Barefoot Med Student! My name is Jess and I’m a podcast producer in NYC for a company called BreakThruRadio. One of the shows I do involves interviewing an awesome blogger (such as yourself!) and I was wondering if you’d like to come on the show as a guest?

    The interview is recorded, not done live (don’t worry!), and takes about thirty minutes. I know you are, of course, very very busy with school, but if you’d have any time in the next couple weeks/any interest, please email me at for more info!



    1. Hi Jess! That’s so nice of you, I feel honoured! I will email you shortly – I’m not sure where to fit it in, but I’m sure we can make a plan!

  2. harveylisam says:

    What an interesting premise! I love dystopian-type novels like this, and it seems like it has a very different twist to it. Another one for the list.

    1. I really liked it! I wish more people would read it though. Feels like it hasn’t really been marketed much.

  3. kmn04books says:

    I’m reading this right now and… it’s so difficult to get used to the language! Does it get any easier? I’m not sure if I can read 640 pages of this (but I hope I can because the story sounds so so interesting!)

    1. Oh yeah, I definitely thought it got easier as time went by! You get more used to the dialect, and you get more drawn into the story, and the other dialects that come into play also make it a bit easier. But mostly I think you just get used to it. I really grew to love it. It is hard, but I felt so accomplished when I reached a point where I no longer took forever to finish a chapter, and I’m so glad I stuck it out! Whereabouts in the book are you now?

      1. kmn04books says:

        Haha I’m only around 60 pages in but I’m already finding it a bit easier to read! I’m a bit impatient so I’m glad to hear it picks up! 😛

Leave a Comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s