Stop telling your depressed friend to go for a run

IMG_9284
Gratuitous selfie at the top of Chapman’s Peak. This was a good day, and I DID feel pretty high.

“Go for a run, you’ll feel better.”

If you’ve ever been sad, you’ll have heard this. If you’ve been depressed, you’ll have heard it ad nauseum.

What depressed person has the energy, let alone the motivation, to go for a run? Realise that “going for a run” is a multiplex of tasks. First, you must get out of bed. Then, you must get dressed. You must put on shoes. You must (preferably) eat something. You must unlock the door. You must step into the sun. You may have to greet the neighbour. You must put one foot in front of the other. Then you must do it faster, and remember to breathe.

Some days the only thing a depressed person can do is get out of bed. Some days, that will be there achievement.

spoon-theory
Image via Odyssey

I’m a runner (sort of). I’ve had the elusive runner’s high. But I’ve always known that running does not and cannot cure my depression. Until recently, I could never substantiate it.

Earlier the year, I attended an Essential Pain Management course, by Professor Romy Parker of UCT*. A large part of the course looks at chronic pain, and naturally there were a lot of parallels with major depression – one such parallel being the endogenous opioid system.

Endogenous opioids are those little chemicals that make you feel good. Endorphins – the ones you get from chocolate and (good) sex? Those are endogenous opioids. The runner’s high involves endogenous opioids (it’s probably a bit more complicated than just that).

averillfwk-fig24_010

As any student of biology will know, for any enzyme/peptide to have an effect on the human body, it must have a receptor. Serotonin has receptors, and that is why we have SSRIs. So do norepinephrine and dopamine. And so do endogenous opioids. If the receptors become damaged, or desensitised, or up- or down-regulated, the effect of that peptide changes. And that is when we get pathology, like depression.

Many people know the monoamine theory of major depression (and much of mental illness, actually). Serotonin, norepinephrine, and dopamine are all monoamines; and the idea is that changes in the levels of these peptides, be it by production or absorption, will bring about changes in mood.

What is less well-known is that many other compounds are involved in the regulation of mood. We know it, but we don’t know it. We talk about endorphins, but we don’t recognise that we are essentially referring to endogenous opioids, and that these therefore play a role.

Much recent research illustrates that opioid receptors in the brains of those with major depression are somehow dysfunctional, compared to the brains of neurotypical individuals. In other words: people with depression (and chronic pain, and some other illnesses) do not get the same effect from endogenous opioids as do healthy people.

So, when you drag your depressed friend out of the door and make them run, you are not helping. They won’t feel better. They started the day off depressed, and after their run they will be out of breath, sweaty, in pain, and still depressed.

There are other ways to help, but this is not one of them.

For more information:

  1. Dysregulation of endogenous opioid emotion regulation circuitry in major depression in women; Kennedy, Koepe, Young et al.
  2. Major Depressive Disorder: Looking Beyond Monoamines (pdf); Gus Alva
  3. Endogenous opioids: The downsides of opposing stress; Valentino, Van Bockstaele

* I highly recommend attending this course if you find one near you. Check out the EPM SA website.

Advertisements

Read This Book: An Unquiet Mind

11552857I love that more healthcare workers are talking about depression these days. It’s something I did not see while I was studying, and that meant that I felt very alone. You might even have seen (or participated in) #crazysocks4docs, which was meant to highlight the high rates of depression in the medical profession. (Some took exception to the term “crazy” – but I’m not going to discuss that right now.)

Anyway, more and more HCWs are doing their part to delegitimise stigma by sharing stories of their own depression. But some mental illnesses are still “off limits” – bipolar mood disorder and schizophrenia, for example; and it’s not hard to know why. For a doctor to get sad and burnt out? Most people can wrap their heads around that. But few are comfortable with the idea of an “unstable” doctor. Society hasn’t become comfortable talking about those disorders that may lead to losing touch with reality. Continue reading “Read This Book: An Unquiet Mind”

8th Annual End of Year Bookish Survey

I’m linking up with Jamie’s annual end of year bookish survey again this year.

I spent 11 months of this year without internet, so I’ve hardly reviewed any books, and posted about books rarely too. I also haven’t read much this year. It’s been a tough one. Jamie has a lot of questions, and I don’t have answers to them all, so I’ve actually left some of them out.

2017-book-survey Continue reading “8th Annual End of Year Bookish Survey”

The Threat of Fun-employment

In final year, we thought that getting an internship post at our desired hospital was the hardest – and most coveted – thing.

Two years later, we all tried to find a community service posting that would give us a foot into the door to our future specialties.

But we didn’t know that those were the easy parts. Then, we still pretty much had guaranteed employment (most of us, at least).

Then came the end of Community Service, and reality hit us in the face: we were on our own.

* * *

That’s where I am now. The government no longer “owes” me a job, and unless I find one, I’ll be unemployed come January 2018. People used to say, “There’s no such thing as an unemployed doctor.” These days, there are plenty of them, because freezing posts is a done thing. Continue reading “The Threat of Fun-employment”

Can I Be A Depressed Doctor?

Ever since I wrote about how going for therapy was my biggest gift to myself*, I’ve met with a few medical students to talk about the topic of mental health. Many of them were worried about their ability to make it through med school with their illness. Many were worried about the viability of a career in medicine with depression.

d57fcdfb544456e8bd23e50d48e641e9

When I was a student, there was a rumour that students with mental illness would be excluded from the course. We were informed by our senior students, and they by theirs, and thus the rumour was propagated. Continue reading “Can I Be A Depressed Doctor?”

Mental Health Begins With Medical Students

Every few months, the mental health of doctors/medical students makes it to popular media. It seems like these spikes in attention occur, and everyone shouts YOU SHOULD CARE FOR YOUR DOCTORS! and then we write blogs and we tweet and we make youtube videos and eventually we go back to work, and nothing has changed.

I think we are the missing link. And by “we”, I mean qualified doctors. And also, you, the older doctors. Continue reading “Mental Health Begins With Medical Students”

The Safe Working Hours Wristband Campaign is Missing the Point – Here’s Why

If you’ve been paying attention, working hours of doctors (especially junior doctors) have been getting some good airtime over the past few months. The Province of the Western Cape has committed to actively reducing maximum continuous working hours for doctors to twenty-four, the HPCSA has promised to “look into it” (not that we have too much confidence there), and our biggest representative, SAMA (South African Medical Association) has come out in our support.

One of the things to come from all this is the launching of an armband campaign. This has its origins, I believe, from a similar campaign in the UK – although I have not been able to find any source to this link.

608772084 Continue reading “The Safe Working Hours Wristband Campaign is Missing the Point – Here’s Why”

Threatened By The People We Serve

A few weeks ago, the community around one of the hospitals where I work picked up their torches and pitchforks (well, sort of) and protested again. I’ve written before about South Africa’s protest state of mind, and about working during a riot.

As it stands, when this specific community protests, they protest right outside the hospital. No matter the reason for protesting, they block all entrances to the hospital and threaten anybody who tries to circumvent them.

fed-up

Police told us to turn around. We called our superiors. They told us to come to work. Continue reading “Threatened By The People We Serve”

A Key To Disillusionment In Work And Play

disillusionment2The phenomenon of disillusionment is well-discussed in the world of medicine. Roundabout third year of medical school, students begin to realise that the medical world simply does not live up to what they envisioned.

It is easy to say, “Just don’t have such high expectations,” but in reality a doctor without vision becomes a mindless drone. Disillusionment is discussed so widely because even though by definition it seems simple, its origins and characteristics are complex.

Funnily enough, I began to really understand disillusionment when I started club-running. Don’t be mistaken: joining a club was the best decision I could have made. It introduced me to many like-minded people and provided ample opportunity to amp my mileage.

I joined a club because I felt that I loved running enough to do so, but not long after joining I started experiencing an emotion I recognised from the medical world. I was feeling disillusioned. Continue reading “A Key To Disillusionment In Work And Play”